About Us

About Shaefer Insurance

Based in Venice, Florida, Shaefer Insurance and our staff are in the business to proficiently and professionally assist you with your insurance needs. We offer all types of insurance, including homeowners, flood, boat, RV, motorcycle and automobile insurance.

Shaefer Insurance is able to offer several benefits to our customers, such as multiple options, local accessibility, knowledge, and experience.

A Variety of Insurance Company Options

As an independent agency, Shaefer Insurance appropriately places insurance with the right companies to fit your needs. This may involve different insurance companies based on your needs and availability but ultimately the policies are under one roof.

We question our customers about their needs then make the appropriate suggestions based upon our experienced knowledge of the industry. Our mission is to educate our customers in order to help them make wise decisions about their insurance needs.”

Local Venice, FL Personal Assistance

Shaefer Insurance customers enjoy being able to walk in to our office at their convenience. Our staff is here from 8:30 to 5:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. We do not sell through an 800 number and clients know who they are dealing with at all times. The office is designed to allow you to work with the same person to develop a confident and trusting relationship.

Our Mission Statement

We are Insurance Professionals.
This means we are prompt, we respond to YOUR inquiries in a timely manner. We are informed, we strive to keep up with industry related issues and maintain an accurate, working knowledge of the products we provide.
We are polite, we want to create a friendly, inviting environment where YOU are welcome. We will endeavor to give you the service you deserve at competitive prices so we can leave you with a lasting impression!
Shaefer Insurance Agency
530 US Hwy 41 Byp South
Unit 8A
Venice, FL 34285
Phone: (941) 485 – 2323

Office Hours
Monday: 9:00am – 5:00pm
Tuesday: 9:00am – 5:00pm
Wednesday: 9:00am – 5:00pm
Thursday: 9:00am – 5:00pm
Friday: 9:00am – 5:00pm
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed