When choosing a Venice Insurance agency to protect your auto, home, or business – you want a company you can trust. Shaefer Insurance is a family owned-and-operated independent insurance agency founded by entrepreneur and agent Brian Shaefer.

As Southwest Florida has grown, we’ve grown too, responding to the changes in the Florida insurance market by constantly looking for the best insurance companies and products to serve our clients. As a Venice Florida independent insurance agency, we can match your individual needs with the products and services of reputable insurance carriers.

The insurance market in Florida is constantly changing and you need good advice to make the best decision when it comes to protecting your family and your property. As your Sarasota County insurance agent, it is our responsibility to provide you the best service and the best coverage at the best possible price.

Our approach is to understand our clients’ situations and match their particular needs to the appropriate insurance product or risk management plan. During the information discovery process, strong and lasting relationships are built with our clients.

We find that meaningful client relationships are the foundation of our business. As an Independent Insurance Agency we are positioned to objectively represent your interests to a wide variety of insurance companies ensuring that you receive the best combination of price and quality available.

We are insurance professionals. This means we are prompt, we respond to YOUR inquiries in a timely manner. We are informed, we strive to keep up with industry related issues and maintain an accurate, working knowledge of the products we provide. We are polite, we want to create a friendly, inviting environment where YOU are welcome. We will endeavor to give you the service you deserve at competitive prices so we can leave you with a lasting impression!


At Shaefer Insurance, we believe in educating our clients on all of your options. Use the form below to request rates and information for your insurance needs.

1 Step 1
Your Nameyour full name
Phone Numberyour full name


brian shaefer insurance

Brian Shaefer

Founder / Owner

Renee Halbek

Renee Halback

Licensed Agent

car insurance quotes venice

Casey Davis

Licensed Agent