Providers

Our Providers

Shaefer Insurance has carefully allied ourselves with premium providers to offer best in class service for all of our customers. Choose a category below to view a list of our providers and get important contact information.

Homeowners Insurance Providers

United Property & Casualty Insurance Company

united_property_casualty_Insurance_company
360 Central Avenue, Suite 900
St. Petersburg, Florida 33701
Voice: (800) 861-4370
Fax: (469) 499-2531
web: www.upcic.com

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company

universal_property_casualty_Insurance_company
1110 W. Commercial Blvd, Suite 300
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309
Voice: (800) 425-9113
Fax: (954) 958-1201
Web: www.universalproperty.com
Email: customerservice@universalproperty.com

Federated National Insurance Company

federated_national_insurance_company
PO Box 407193
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33340
Voice: (800) 293-2532
Fax: (954) 733-7071
Web: www.myfnic.com
Email: uwinfo@tchcusa.com

American Strategic Insurance Company

American_Strategic_Insurance_Company
805 Executive Center Dr. W, Suite 300
St. Petersburg, FL 33702
Voice: 866-274-8765
Fax: 866-274-3299
Web: www.americanstrategic.com
Email: claims@asicorp.org

Olympus Insurance Company

Olympus_Insurance_Company
Voice: (800) 711-9386
Fax: (866) 716-6927
Web: www.olympusfl.com
Email: info@oigfl.com

Citizens Insurance Company

Citizens_Insurance_Company
P.O. Box 17219
Jacksonville, FL 32245-7219
Voice: (888) 685-1555
Web: citizensfla.com

Bankers Insurance Company

PO Box 15707
St. Petersburg, FL 33733-5707
Voice: (800) 627-0000
Web: www.bankersinsurance.com
 
Auto Insurance Providers

Travelers Insurance Company of Florida

Mercury Insurance Company

mercury
Voice: (800) 503-3724
Web: www.mercuryinsurance.com

Progressive insurance Companies

progressive
Web: www.progressive.com
Voice: (800) 776-4737

Infinity Insurance Company

infinity
P.O. Box 830189
Birmingham, AL 35283-0189
Voice: (800) 782-1020
Web: www.infinityauto.com
Email: customer.service@ipacc.com

Foremost Insurance Company

foremost
P.O. Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
Voice: (800) 527-3905
Fax: (800) 325-1507
Web: www.foremost.com
 
Life Insurance Providers

Ohio National Life Insurance Company

ohio_national
One Financial Way
Cincinnati, Ohio 45242
Voice: (513) 794.6100
Web: www.ohionational.com