We’re Here to Help.

Explore the best approach to insurance. Shaefer Insurance Agency has been educating clients and serving South Florida since 2006.

low cost insurance quotes

home insurance Sarasota County

HOME INSURANCE

sarasota car insurance

CAR INSURANCE

sarasota boat insurance company

BOAT INSURANCE

best motorcycle insurance quotes

MOTORCYCLE INSURANCE

life insurance quotes Sarasota

LIFE INSURANCE

flood insurance in Florida

FLOOD INSURANCE

Welcome to Shaefer Insurance Agency

Since 2006, Shaefer Insurance Agency has been the leading choice for quality insurance solutions in Venice, FL. Whether you need homeowners insurance, car insurance, life insurance, or a combination of different policies, we can provide the right solutions. We are a family owned and operated independent insurance agency that is committed to finding the most affordable plans for you. Count on us for competitive rates on auto insurance, flood insurance, boat insurance, and much more.

A Name You can Trust

As one of the most trusted insurance companies, Shaefer Insurance Agency is here to help meet all of your personal insurance needs. We aim to fully understand each client’s situation in order to offer the best match for their unique situation. Purchasing the right insurance policy isn’t always easy. With such a diversity in companies, it can be challenging to know which one to select. That is where our insurance agency comes in. We will be here every step of the way helping you to make the best possible selection for your needs.

Choosing The Right Policy

Whether you are choosing home insurance or flood insurance, it helps to know that Shaefer Insurance Agency is by your side. Since we are an independent agency, we serve our customers instead of the insurance companies. You can rest assured knowing you are getting the best advice and recommendations when choosing a policy with us.

Get a FREE Quote

Contact us to receive a free quote about our insurance solutions. Give us a call at (941) 485-2323 today.

Find Information &
Free Tips!

[]
1 Step 1
Previous
Next

What Our Clients Say

My wife and I have had Shaefer Insurance dealing with our insurance needs since moving to the area from Ft Lauderdale eight years ago. Started out as just vehicle insurance and then we continued with them when we purchased our home and needed insurance. Everything is so easy and all the associates from the receptionist you first meet walking in to the owner of the agency are all a delight to deal with. Thank you all and we look forward to continuing our relationship.

–David D.

Easy to work with. Very honest. They spent lots of time explaining coverage’s and helping me make the right choices. Highly recommend them to all my friends and family!

–Mark G.

Awesome communication! Efficient, and cares about their customer’s!!! Highly recommend!

–Krystal M.

CONTACT INFO

2379 E. Venice Ave, Venice, FL 34292

Phone: (941) 485 – 2323

Email: csr@shaeferinsurance.com

HOURS OF OPERATION

Monday

9:00am – 5:00pm

Tuesday

9:00am – 5:00pm

Wednesday

9:00am – 5:00pm

Thursday

9:00am – 5:00pm

Friday

9:00am – 5:00pm

Saturday

Appointment Only

Sunday

Appointment Only

LET’S TALK.

Use the form below to get a free quote for your and information for your insurance needs. You’ll be glad you did.

[]
1 Step 1
Your Nameyour full name
Phone Numberyour full name
Current Street Addressyour full name
Effective date of current policy?
Previous
Next

best Sarasota insurance quotes